Red fir, a common softwood in certain regions, often presents itself as a readily available and affordable option. But is red fir good firewood?
We will explore the pros and cons of using red fir as firewood, delving into its burning qualities, comparing it to other popular choices, and ultimately helping you decide if it's the right fuel for your fireside needs.
Is Red Fir Right for You?
The answer depends largely on your heating priorities and circumstances.
If you live in a milder climate and are looking for firewood primarily for ambiance and supplemental heat, red fir can be a suitable option.
It’s an attractive choice because it is:
- easy to split
- readily available in certain regions
- affordable
It's perfect for those cozy evenings by the fire where high heat output isn't the primary concern.
However, if you rely on firewood as your primary heat source during harsh winters, or if you need long-lasting fires for overnight burns, red fir may not be the best choice. Its lower BTU output and faster burn time mean you'll need a significantly larger volume of wood compared to hardwoods, potentially offsetting any cost savings.
In these cases, denser hardwoods like oak or maple would be a more efficient and effective option.
Consider these key takeaways when making your decision:
- Budget: Red fir is generally more affordable than hardwoods.
- Heating Needs: Prioritize hardwoods for primary heating; consider red fir for supplemental heat or ambiance.
- Convenience: Red fir is easier to split and handle.
- Availability: Red fir's availability varies regionally.
- Burning Characteristics: Red fir burns quickly with moderate heat output and can produce smoke if not properly seasoned.
Keep reading for more details & tips…
Table of Contents
- Red Fir Firewood: Understanding the Basics
- Burning Qualities of Red Fir
- Pros and Cons of Using Red Fir Firewood
- Seasoning and Storing Red Fir Firewood
- Red Fir vs. Other Popular Firewood Options
Additional Tables:
Red Fir Firewood: Understanding the Basics
Red fir ( Abies magnifica ) is a coniferous evergreen tree native to the mountains of the western United States, specifically Oregon and California. It thrives in higher elevations and is known for its tall, straight trunk and distinctive reddish-brown bark, hence the name "red fir."
This readily available resource makes it a popular choice for firewood in its native range. However, its availability and cost can vary significantly depending on your location. In regions outside its natural habitat, red fir may be less common and potentially more expensive.
Red fir is classified as a softwood, meaning it comes from coniferous trees. This distinguishes it from hardwoods like oak and maple, which come from deciduous trees.
Generally, softwoods are less dense than hardwoods. This lower density affects how red fir burns, influencing its heat output and burn time.
Related: Hardwood vs. Softwood Firewood: Which is Right for You?
Burning Qualities of Red Fir
Now that we understand the basics of red fir, let's delve into the heart of the matter: how does it actually burn? Several factors contribute to the overall burning quality of any firewood.
Heat Output
Red fir has a moderate BTU rating, typically ranging from 19.1 to 21.3 million BTU per cord. This places it on the lower end of the heat output spectrum compared to hardwoods like oak (24-28 million BTU) or maple (25-27 million BTU).
While red fir won't produce the intense, long-lasting heat of these denser hardwoods, it's still capable of providing decent warmth, making it suitable for milder climates or supplemental heating.
It's ideal for creating ambiance and a pleasant fire, rather than being your primary heat source during frigid winters.
Flame Characteristics
Red fir produces a relatively quick, bright flame. Because it's less dense, it ignites easily and burns rapidly. This can be advantageous for getting a fire started quickly, but it also means you'll need to add wood to the fire more frequently compared to hardwoods.
The flames are generally less robust and more flickering than those produced by denser woods.
Smoke Production
One potential drawback of red fir is its smoke production. When properly seasoned, the smoke output is moderate. However, if the wood isn't adequately dried, red fir can produce a significant amount of smoke, which can be problematic for indoor fireplaces and contribute to creosote buildup in your chimney.
Proper seasoning is crucial for minimizing smoke and maximizing burning efficiency.
Aroma
Red fir has a mild, slightly sweet aroma when burned. It's not as distinctive or pronounced as some other wood types, like pine or cedar, but it generally doesn't produce an unpleasant odor. Most find its scent unobtrusive and pleasant enough for indoor use.
Coal Production
Due to its lower density, red fir doesn't produce long-lasting coals like hardwoods. While it creates a decent bed of embers, they tend to burn down relatively quickly.
This makes red fir less suitable for overnight burns or situations where you need a sustained heat source.
Pros and Cons of Using Red Fir Firewood
Like any firewood option, red fir has its advantages and disadvantages. Weighing these pros and cons will help you determine if it's the right choice for your specific needs.
Pros
- Easy to Split and Handle: It’s easy to split, even with a hand axe, and its lighter weight also makes it easier to transport and handle.
- Relatively Affordable: In regions where red fir is abundant, it tends to be a more affordable firewood option compared to hardwoods.
- Good for Quick Fires and Ambiance: Red fir's quick ignition and bright flame make it ideal for starting a fire quickly and creating a pleasant, flickering ambiance.
- Pleasant Aroma: The mild, slightly sweet scent of burning red fir is generally considered pleasant and unobtrusive, adding to the overall enjoyment of a fire.
Cons
- Lower BTU Output: Red fir's lower BTU rating means it produces less heat compared to hardwoods. This makes it less suitable for primary heating in colder climates.
- Potential for Creosote Buildup: If not properly seasoned, red fir can produce a significant amount of smoke, which contributes to creosote buildup in chimneys; a potential fire hazard.
- Burns Faster: Red fir's lower density causes it to burn more quickly than hardwoods, requiring more frequent replenishing of the wood supply.
- Not Ideal for Long-Lasting Fires: The coals produced by red fir burn down relatively quickly, making it less suitable for overnight burns or when a sustained heat source is needed.
Seasoning and Storing Red Fir Firewood
Proper seasoning is crucial for getting the most out of your red fir firewood. Seasoning refers to the process of drying the wood to reduce its moisture content. Burning green or unseasoned wood reduces heat output, increases smoke production, and the risk of creosote buildup in your chimney.
How Long to Season Red Fir
Ideally, red fir should be seasoned for at least six months, but up to a year is recommended for optimal burning. The longer the wood dries, the lower the moisture content, and the better it will burn.
Best Practices for Stacking and Storing:
- Split the Wood: Splitting the wood into smaller pieces significantly increases the surface area exposed to air, accelerating the drying process.
- Elevate the Wood: Stack the wood on a raised platform or pallets to prevent it from absorbing moisture from the ground.
- Stack in a Sunny and Windy Location: Choose a location that receives ample sunlight and good airflow. This helps to evaporate the moisture from the wood.
- Cover the Top: Protect the woodpile from rain and snow by covering the top with a tarp or other waterproof material. Ensure the sides remain open for adequate ventilation.
- Stack Loosely: Don't pack the wood too tightly. Leave space between the pieces for air to circulate freely.
Related: How to Stack Firewood Like a Pro
By following these seasoning and storage guidelines, you can ensure your red fir firewood burns efficiently, produces minimal smoke, and provides optimal heat output.
Related: Learn How to Season Firewood Properly
Red Fir vs. Other Popular Firewood Options
Choosing the right firewood often involves comparing different species to find the best fit for your needs. Here's how red fir stacks up against some other popular firewood options:
| Firewood Type | BTU (million BTU/cord) | Burn Time | Smoke Output | Ease of Splitting | Heat Intensity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Red Fir | 19.1 - 21.3 | Moderate | Moderate (when seasoned) | Easy | Moderate |
| Oak | 24 - 28 | Long | Low (when seasoned) | Moderate to Difficult | High |
| Maple | 25 - 27 | Long | Low (when seasoned) | Moderate | High |
| Pine | 14 - 17 | Short | High | Easy | Low |
| Douglas Fir | 20 - 22 | Moderate | Moderate (when seasoned) | Easy | Moderate |
As you can see, red fir falls in the middle ground in terms of BTU output and burn time. While it doesn't provide the long-lasting heat of hardwoods like oak and maple, it burns hotter and longer than pine. It's also easier to split than oak, making it a more convenient option for some.
Douglas fir offers similar performance to red fir, representing another viable softwood option. Ultimately, the best choice for you will depend on your priorities, whether you prioritize heat output, burn time, ease of splitting, or affordability.
More Articles for You: