Two of the most popular hardwoods for flooring are maple and hickory, both known for their durability and classic appeal. But which one is better for your home?
In this article, we’ll compare their appearance, durability, maintenance needs, and cost to help you make the best decision for your lifestyle and budget.
| Feature | Maple | Hickory |
|---|---|---|
| Appearance | Smooth, uniform grain, light color | Dramatic, varied grain, rich color |
| Durability | High (Janka Hardness: 1450) | Very High (Janka Hardness: 1820) |
| Scratch Resistance | Good | Excellent |
| Maintenance | Easy, regular cleaning required | Easy, regular cleaning required |
| Water Resistance | Moderate | Moderate |
| Cost | Mid-range | Higher Mid-range to High |
| Style | Contemporary, Traditional, Versatile | Rustic, Traditional, Farmhouse |
| Best For | Moderate traffic areas, contemporary homes | High traffic areas, active families, rustic homes |
| Pros | Classic look, good durability, versatile style | Exceptional durability, striking appearance, character |
| Cons | Can show scratches, susceptible to moisture | Can be expensive, busy grain pattern may not suit all styles |
Table of Contents
Maple Flooring
Maple flooring is a beloved choice for its clean, timeless look and impressive durability. Known for its smooth surface and subtle grain pattern, it offers a versatile backdrop for various interior design styles.
Let's explore the key characteristics that make maple flooring a popular option:
Appearance
Maple's fine, uniform grain pattern creates a smooth, even surface. Its natural color ranges from creamy white and pale beige to light reddish-brown hues.
While it lacks the dramatic graining of some other hardwoods, this understated elegance allows maple to seamlessly integrate into various design schemes, from contemporary minimalist to traditional farmhouse.
Variations in color and grain are more pronounced in species like soft maple, while hard maple offers a more consistent and uniform look.
Figured maple, with its unique "birdseye" or "curly" patterns, adds a touch of visual interest and can be a striking focal point in a room.
Durability
Hard maple, in particular, boasts excellent durability, making it a practical choice for high-traffic areas. With a Janka hardness rating of 1450, it's harder than many other popular hardwoods like oak and cherry.
This resistance to dents and scratches ensures that maple flooring can withstand the wear and tear of daily life and maintain its beauty for years to come.
Soft maple, while slightly less durable than hard maple, still offers good performance and is suitable for areas with moderate traffic.
Maintenance
Maple's smooth surface makes it relatively easy to clean and maintain.
- Regular sweeping or vacuuming with a soft-bristle attachment will remove dust and debris.
- Occasionally, damp mopping with a wood floor cleaner can help restore its shine.
However, due to its hardness, maple can be susceptible to scratches from heavy objects or pet claws. Protective mats and felt pads under furniture can help minimize damage.
Additionally, maple is more sensitive to moisture than some other hardwoods, so spills should be wiped up promptly to prevent staining or warping.
Related: How to Care for Maple Hardwood Floors
Cost
Maple flooring generally falls within a mid-range price point for hardwoods. The cost can vary depending on factors such as the grade of the wood, the width of the planks, and the type of finish.
While it might be slightly more expensive than some entry-level hardwoods, maple's durability and timeless appeal offer excellent long-term value.
Related: Should You Choose Maple Floors? Pros and Cons Revealed
Hickory Flooring
If you're looking for a hardwood floor with character and visual impact, hickory is an excellent choice. Known for its dramatic grain patterns and rich color variation, hickory brings rustic, natural beauty to any space.
Let's delve into the key features of hickory flooring:
Appearance
Hickory is prized for its striking appearance, characterized by bold, contrasting grain patterns and a wide range of color variations. From creamy white and beige to warm browns, reds, and even hints of gold, hickory displays a natural color palette that adds depth and visual interest to any room.
Its dramatic knots and swirling grain patterns create a rustic, character-rich look that's perfect for adding warmth and personality to a space.
Durability
Hickory is renowned for its exceptional hardness and durability. With a Janka hardness rating of 1820, it significantly surpasses maple and many other popular hardwood species in its resistance to dents, scratches, and wear.
This makes hickory an ideal choice for high-traffic areas, homes with active families, and spaces where durability is a top priority. It can handle the rigors of daily life with grace, maintaining its beauty for generations.
Maintenance
Maintaining hickory flooring is similar to maple, requiring regular sweeping or vacuuming and occasional damp mopping with a wood floor cleaner.
While its hardness provides excellent resistance to scratches, it's still a good idea to use protective mats and furniture pads to minimize potential damage.
Like maple, hickory is susceptible to moisture damage, so spills should be cleaned up promptly to prevent staining or warping.
Cost
Hickory flooring tends to be slightly more expensive than maple due to its high demand and exceptional durability.
The cost can fluctuate based on factors like:
- the grade of the wood
- plank width
- and finish
While it represents a higher initial investment, hickory's long lifespan and enduring beauty make it a worthwhile investment for homeowners seeking a durable and visually striking floor.
Related: Must-Know Pros and Cons of Hickory Flooring
Which Flooring is Right for You?
Choosing between maple and hickory ultimately depends on your individual needs, priorities, and aesthetic preferences. Here's a breakdown to help you navigate the decision:
Consider Your Lifestyle
- Active Households/Pets: If you have children, pets, or a busy household, hickory's superior durability makes it a more practical choice. Its resistance to scratches and dents will help your floors withstand the daily wear.
- Quieter Environments: Maple's slightly softer nature might offer a marginally quieter floor underfoot compared to hickory, which can be a factor in apartments or homes with shared living spaces.
Think About Your Style
- Contemporary/Minimalist: Maple's clean lines and subtle grain lend themselves well to modern and minimalist interiors. Its light color can create a sense of spaciousness and airiness.
- Rustic/Traditional/Farmhouse: Hickory's dramatic grain and rich color variations are a perfect fit for rustic, traditional, or farmhouse-style homes. It adds warmth, character, and a touch of natural beauty.
- Versatile: Maple's adaptable nature allows it to complement a broader range of design styles, making it a safe choice if you're unsure about a specific aesthetic.
Factor in Your Budget
- Value: While maple typically sits at a mid-range price point, hickory's exceptional durability and longevity can offer better long-term value despite the higher initial cost.
- Return on Investment: Both maple and hickory can increase your home's resale value, but hickory's premium status might offer a slight edge in certain markets.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your unique circumstances. Carefully consider the factors discussed above and envision how each wood would look and function in your home.
Ordering samples and seeing the wood in person can also help you make a confident decision.
More Articles for You: